GTA Mandy

Chapter 1 · Fences · Spoilers

Brian or Donnie: who should you sell to?

Donnie pays more: $3,400 against Brian's $2,720 for the same cocaine drops in Chapter 1. Sell to Brian anyway unless Donnie will have paid you before you start Swamped: Donnie dies in that mission, his trailer stops buying, and payments he still owes you can be affected.

Checked against launch-week walkthroughs · Updated

Reddit

Illustration of a weathered storage lockup with a metal deposit box by its padlocked door, and an old camper trailer across a gravel lot at dusk
Illustration of the two drop-offs: a lockup like Brian's and a trailer like Donnie's. Not a game screenshot.
Donnie pays
$3,400 for Cal's drops
Brian pays
$2,720 for the same
Both buy
Narcotics, marked bills, jewelry
Paid into
Jason's mailbox
Donnie's deadline
Before Swamped

Donnie's Trailer or Brian's Lockup

Both fences are in Key Lento and buy the same three kinds of goods: narcotics, marked bills and jewelry. You leave the goods in a deposit box and the money follows later. Hover over a fence's icon on the map to see what it is paying.

Donnie's Trailer

Opens as a fence after Clean Up After Donnie. The better payer: Pro-Gamer's rate table puts it at Low for narcotics and Very Low for jewelry and marked bills. It closes for good in Swamped, when Donnie dies.

Brian's Lockup

Very Low for all three in the same table, so less than Donnie for narcotics. It's the fence Cal tells you to use, and it keeps buying through the rest of Chapter 1.

For Cal's cocaine drops after Clean Up After Donnie, GamesRadar and Pro-Gamer both got $3,400 from Donnie and $2,720 from Brian: $680, or 25%, more at the trailer.

How selling works

  1. Pick a fence

    Both deposit boxes are in Key Lento. Compare what each is paying on the map before you drive over.

  2. Drop the goods

    Leave the narcotics, marked bills or jewelry in the fence's deposit box. Neither fence pays on the spot.

  3. Wait for the money

    The payment lands in the mailbox at Jason's house after a short delay. Guides give no exact time, and players say Donnie's money is slower to arrive than Brian's.

  4. If Brian's money is late

    An active Brian story mission can hold up his payments. Finish it, then check the mailbox again.

Why Cal says Brian: the Swamped problem

Cal's advice is a hint. Donnie dies in Swamped, later in Chapter 1, and his trailer stops working as a fence for good. GamesRadar and Pro-Gamer both warn that money he still owes you can be affected, and Reddit players report the same.

So the extra $680 is only safe if Donnie has paid you before you start Swamped. If that mission is already on your map, or you're playing the story straight through, the lockup is the safer drop.

Player poll

Who did you sell to: Donnie or Brian?

Tap an answer to see how other players voted.

What's confirmed and what isn't

Each claim is labelled by its source.

  1. Widely reported

    Donnie pays about 25% more

    GamesRadar and Pro-Gamer both report $3,400 from Donnie against $2,720 from Brian for Cal's cocaine drops.

  2. Widely reported

    Donnie's fence ends in Swamped

    Donnie dies in that mission and his trailer stops buying. GamesRadar and Pro-Gamer both warn that unpaid money can be affected.

  3. One outlet only

    The rate tiers

    Low and Very Low come from Pro-Gamer's table. The map shows each fence's current rate, so check it before you sell.

  4. Player reports

    Donnie pays more slowly

    Players on Reddit say Donnie's money takes longer to reach the mailbox than Brian's.

  5. Unconfirmed

    Brian's Lockup after Chapter 1

    Guides call it safe through Chapter 1. Whether it keeps buying later in the game isn't confirmed in anything we've read.

Questions

Who pays more, Brian or Donnie?

Donnie. For Cal's cocaine drops he pays $3,400 and Brian $2,720, about 25% more.

Should I sell to Brian or Donnie in GTA 6?

Brian, unless Donnie will have paid you before you start Swamped. Donnie dies in that mission, and money he still owes you can be affected.

What can you sell to Brian and Donnie?

Narcotics, marked bills and jewelry. Both fences buy all three.

Where do Brian and Donnie pay you?

In the mailbox at Jason's house, a while after you drop the goods off.

What happens to Donnie's trailer after Swamped?

It stops working as a fence. In Don Gone, the next job, Jason clears it out.

Player notes

Who did you sell to, and did Donnie's money ever arrive?

Plain text, public. Links are rejected.

Loading notes…